Google

Tuesday, March 28, 2006

Uniforms: Do they really improve learning?


The military wears them. Postal workers, sports teams, even men and women in factories at times wear them. Now it appears if you go to Dudley High School in Greensboro NC you will wear them as well. The "them" I speak of is uniforms. Dudley HS needed 88% of the parents that voted to approve of uniforms. As of today, March 28, 2006, we now know that 89% approve of having uniforms at the school for next year.
All the buzz about uniforms began officially on March 21st when a "fashion show" was given for the community to view the uniforms and vote (only parents were allowed to vote). It was immediately evident that students and their parents were torn on the issue. Amos Quick, the District 9 school board representative that represents Dudley said, "I like to see kids look nice, look neat, look a little more professional than sometimes they look now." Not only is Quick a school board member, but also a parent of a freshman at the school who strongly opposed her father's view of a "professional look." "I would feel better if they voted against it, but I can't change their minds. I've been trying to change their minds for so long," says Dudley freshman Jasmine Quick. Other comments made by Ms. Jasmine Quick were along the lines of "...we should be able to express ourselves." However, one of the biggest reasons for this sudden move to wear uniforms is due to the very fact of expression and oftentimes the misuse of it, often to the detriment of education.
So why is it that now Dudley wants to move to uniforms? Simply put, academic research has stated its benefits. One particular study found thatfor secondary schools, "Marked differences could mainly be observed at upper grade levels, where the uniform is worn for a longer time: At these grade level, students wearing uniforms compared to those not wearing uniforms reported a better classroom climate, a higher learning goal orientation, higher classroom attention and a lower importance of clothes." (Dickhauser et al., 2004) Other studies within the topic of uniforms showed similar correlations.
The question still lingers, should students be allowed to express themselves? There are intend positives to the uniform issue, like detering gang paraphanalia, more professional dress, and some economic reasons as well, but in the long run is this in the best interest of the student when we force them to wear a uniform. Many of the parents in attendance to view the uniforms on March 21st saw much promise in the prospect of wearing them, but many of the students already are seeking transfer to other schools. Does this speak to the need for students to get back on focus or a silent protest against the powers that be? Let me know what you think about school uniforms in public schools: Yes or no? and Why?

Dickhauser, O., Lutz, K., Wenzel, M.,& Schone, C. Correlates of student uniforms: An empirical analysis. PSYCHOLOGIE IN ERZIEHUNG UND UNTERRICHT 51 (4): 296-308. 2004

4 Comments:

Blogger Dr. Pryor said...

Here is an update of some of the quotes taken from the Greensboro News & Record from Mar. 30,2006.
"We believe that teh dress standards that are currently in place sometimes serve as disruptions during the instructional school day. [Uniforms] will create a different environment."
Mrs. Phyllis Martin, Principal of Dudley HS

"When people dress up, they have different attitudes. Look at how differently students behave when they wear their military uniforms."
Mrs. Drennan Rhyne, Drama teacher at Dudley HS

"Requirng uniforms would prevent students from wearing gang colors to school, provoking confrontations."
Dr. Terry Grier, Superintendent of Guilford County Schools

"Uniforms will not mend all of our problems, or any high school's problems, but they will help to stop some things. I think it is a step in the right direction."
Mr. F. Christopher Goins, Social Studies teacher at Dudley HS

"I just think it's [wearing a uniform] a positive image that makes me look good."
Miss Michaela Leak, Junior at Dudley HS

9:48 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

It's great that Dudley has the vision to us this simple tool to have the students focus on completing their education rather than "What to Wear today?" To Ms Quick and other students who say they need to express themselves I say, "Express yourself wearing your uniform by getting the best education possible. I depending on you and your generation to be our future leaders."

12:58 AM  
Blogger Dr. Pryor said...

Here is another update that is somewhat related to the topic:
I am a tenth grade student with a GPA of 4.25. I am writing on the topic of James B. Dudley HS and the issues incorporated with the school.
My problem is not that we have to get uniforms, it is that we have no voice in the issues. As high schoolers, we are supposed to be getting prepared for the real world, and in the real world you have choices. Some of us fell as though we have none.
Guilford County wants us to bring up our scores, and I can understand that, but do uniforms accomplish that, or does taking down all the extracurricular trophies in the trophy case help us to want to succeed? No. What it does is make some want to rebel.
The motivations that we have are in those trophies, and it is not like Dudley does not have academic achievements posted. All you have to do islook at the trophy case or on the acceptance letter or SAT board. It seems the media and Guilford County want to prtray Dudley as a horrible place to be and, really, you cannot judge unless you are there.
Domonique Garland, from the March 31, 2006 Greensboro News and Record Letters to the Editor

10:21 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

"Yall Crazy" to have to wear school uniform it "SUCKS" for you.. We get to have cell phones and wear what we want to wear.....

2:54 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home